Which subtotal best reflects core operating performance befo…
Which subtotal best reflects core operating performance before financing and taxes?
Which subtotal best reflects core operating performance befo…
Questions
Which subtоtаl best reflects cоre оperаting performаnce before financing and taxes?
Pick оne оf the fоllowing two: (7) Sаlt is soluble, diаmonds аre not. The one has a power or capacity the other doesn’t: Salt if immersed in whatever will dissolve, but diamonds if immersed in water will not dissolve. Suppose some bit of salt and some particular diamond are never immersed in water, and holding fixed all the causal antecedents and the laws of nature, they couldn’t have been immersed in water. Suppose that based on those facts someone were to deny that the salt is soluble and say that there is in fact no difference between salt and the diamond. Why would that be incorrect? Make the analogy with Moore’s ‘could have done otherwise’ condition. Moore says some people have a power to act otherwise that others don’t. He understands having that power as entailing that “If the one had chosen otherwise, he would have done otherwise”, and a person’s not having that power as entailing that, “if he chose otherwise, he wouldn’t do otherwise’”. Explain how someone who says that there isn’t a difference between the people unless the one could also have chosen otherwise misses the point or says something false. Hint --Abilities/dispositions are not extinguished because they are not made manifest. Explain. OR (8) Explain the analogy we (Stampe and Gibson) make between a free working will and a free working weathervane. Explain, on our view, when the will is free-working, and when it is not. Explain why whether the will is free-working or not has nothing to do with the truth of determinism. In fact, the will is free when it is determined by certain kinds of factors. Explain what the relevant factors are. Give an example of a person who makes a rational decision in the circumstances, but who does not do what she does of her own free will, because she couldn’t choose otherwise (in the sense we require). Explain how on our view, a person’s will is completely free only if she could make whatever decision might be rational. Take an example and show how the greater capacity a person has to make rational decisions, the more free she is. Be clear that you understand the rationality of the decisions in terms of what is ’subjectively’ rational.